Digitizing Wealth Management – The Rise of Robo-Advisors
Fintech stands for financial technology. It’s just a blanket term for technology that is disrupting the financial services industry. Payments, Blockchain, Robo-Advisors (or automated investment advisory services) are all segments in Fintech.
Why robo-advisors? We are in the early stages of a shift in wealth management, especially “plain vanilla” investing for the mass affluent and millennial segment. Until recently, you had only two options when investing:
- Do-it-yourself (DIY)
- Hire a registered investment advisor (RIA)
Now there is a third option. Robo-advisors are new a class of financial advisors that provides online, algorithm based portfolio management with minimal human intervention. Robo-Advisors going after the low-end of brokerage/RIA business with automated asset allocation.
The Robo-Advisors market leaders who are serving the mass affluent include are:
- Wealthfront (with over USD 2.6bn in assets under management (AuM) and 20,000 investors);
- Betterment (with over USD 1.4bn in AuM and 70,000 investors); and
- FutureAdvisor (With over $600 million in AUM).
The timing for this market shift coincides with three trends: consumerization, digital tools, and disillusionment with status-quo investment advisors. The gyrating stock market driven by program trading is increasingly bringing Robo-Advisors, algorithmic portfolio management to the forefront. Investors are getting disillusioned with traditional investment advisors who simply track the market indices (SPY, QQQ or Russell 2000) by purchasing ETFs at best.
Many banks and brokerage firms over the years have shifted their focus to serve ultra high net worth (UHNW) and high net worth (HNW) investors, leaving an opportunity for firms to target the “mass affluent” investors, or those with less than $1 million in investable assets. Younger investors are increasingly interested in online digital advice, as opposed to hiring an adviser.
What Problem are Robo-Advisors Solving?
Historically the problem with trying to get an RIA was many have minimum investable assets of $500,000 or larger. This requirement puts many RIAs out of reach for younger, or mass affluent individuals. So these individuals had to fend for themselves or take generic advise from different sources.
In addition, it’s not uncommon for RIAs to charge 1-2% annually. That’s 1-2% you have to do better than the market every year just to keep up. As history has shown, fees are the worst way to reduce returns. The issue for many individuals is they aren’t cut out to manage their investments or retirement accounts. 401(k) plans and IRA accounts puts individuals in the investment driver’s seat. Many of which do not have the time to read up on investment analysis. Worst yet, may have poor investing psychology and jump out of the market at the absolute worst times (buy high and sell low).
Robo-advisors, algorithmic portfolio management, today offers a brand new option in wealth management. Rather than focusing on data analysis by humans, the objective is to have tools that perform analysis and make decisions autonomously. WealthFront, a robo-advisor, now claims $2.6 bln in assets under management (AUM).
- Most Robo-Advisors seek the mass affluent (< USD200k) by offering fully automated and affordable portfolio management service
- Robo-Advisors are offering Automated Portfolio Management – Platforms like Collective2 and Covestor allow investors to synch their brokerage accounts to an automated trading strategy
- Schwab, Vanguard, et al following with their own Robo-Advisor offerings. BlackRock. the asset management giant, is acquiring robo-advisor, FutureAdvisor.
- Many Robo-Advisors that had only proposed B2C services, are now offering their digital expertise to traditional advisors so that they can enhance their end client services. For example, Fidelity Instituational Wealth Services (IWS) teamed-up with Betterment to provide Betterment Institutional services to their 3,000 Registered Investment Advisors (RIA) firms.
- Financial institutions can either offer these clients a digital advice offering or they can use the offering to complement a broker.
Digital Advice: The Rise of Robo-Advisors
Since 2009, more than 200 FinTech companies have jumped into the fledgling business of helping investors plan their portfolios online, from startups like WealthFront to fund giants Fidelity and Vanguard to brokerage firms such as Charles Schwab.
These Robo Advisers services share a common approach: using automation and models to select investments that meet clients’ temperament and goals. They also share a focus on low or even no fees, which has higher-priced brokers and registered advisers worried about their profit margins.
The use cases for Robo-Advisors include:
- Automatic Portfolio rebalancing
- Tax-loss Harvesting
- Customized Portfolios
- Diversification models
Below is a table that compares the different service offerings.
|Wealthfront||Free for first $15k, 0.25%/annually for anything higher||$500|
|Betterment||0.15% – 0.35%/annually||None – less than $10k must deposit $100/mo or pay $3/mo|
|Financial Guard||$15.95/month $149.95/annually||$1,000|
|LearnVest||$299/setup and $19/month||None|
|MarketRiders||$14.95/month + trading fees||None|
|Personal Capital||0.49% – 0.89%/annually depending the amount invested||$100,000|
|Rebalance IRA||0.50%/annually, $250 setup fee, and trading fees, min $500/year||None|
|TradeKing Advisors||0.25%/annually – Core
0.50%/annually – Momentum
|$5,000 – Core
$25,000 – Momentum
|Vanguard Personal Advisor Services||0.30%/annually||$50,000|
How Robo-Advisors work
The first step is to fill out an online questionnaire to gauge users’ risk tolerance. Here’s a sampling of their questions.
- “The global stock market is often volatile. If your entire investment portfolio lost 10% of its value in a month during a market decline, what would you do?” Possible answers: sell all of your investments; sell some; keep all; buy more. (Wealthfront)
- “When it comes to making important financial decisions…”Possible answers: I try to avoid making decisions; I reluctantly make decisions; I confidently make decisions and don’t look back. (Charles Schwab)
- “If a family member or friend who knows you well were to describe you, they would generally say you are…” Possible answers: cautious by nature; a risk taker; somewhere in between cautious and a risk taker. (Hedgeable)
- “How do you feel about this statement: ‘I’m comfortable with investments that may experience frequent, large declines in market value if there is a potential for higher returns.’ ” Possible answers: strongly disagree; disagree; somewhat agree; agree; strongly agree (TradeKing Advisors)
Robo-advisors, then, recommend portfolios of low-cost exchange-traded funds based on online questionnaires that investors fill out. They tend to charge annual management fees ranging from 0.25% to 0.75% of assets plus fund expenses—compared with the 1% plus fund expenses traditional advisers often charge. The idea is that investors will fare better with low fees and broadly diversified portfolios.
The firms use algorithms to place investors into various portfolios based on risk tolerance. But each has its own particular bias. Consider the differences between the two startups that have garnered the most attention: San Francisco-based Wealthfront and New York-based Betterment.
Wealthfront puts from 5% to 28% of its portfolios into emerging-market stocks, which tend to be more volatile. Betterment puts a greater emphasis on stocks of smaller U.S. companies and those that are believed to be trading at a discount.
That can add up to big differences. An investor with a moderate bent at Wealthfront, for example, would end up with 35% of his portfolio in U.S. large-company stocks and 14% in emerging-market stocks. A moderate investor at Betterment would end up with a smaller share of U.S. large-company stocks but more in U.S. small-company stocks—and only 6% in emerging-market stocks.
The traditional Do-It-Self (DIY) and Registered Investment Advisors (RIA) market segment is going to face increased competition from Robo-Advisors, algorithmic portfolio management, companies.
In the next five years, more than $2 trillion in wealth is expected to transfer between generations. The millennials who are increasingly social, mobile, connected are seeking significantly more digital tools for managing wealth. We are replacing human beings with the right technology tools….similar to other industries with intermediaries like travel agents, reservation clerks, etc.
Assets managed by Internet-age advisers are a tiny but fast-growing piece of the $18 trillion wealth-management market, which encompasses everything from the newest online advisers to old-school brokerage firms. Digital wealth-management assets, which include those managed by robo advisers as well as traditional firms with online offerings, are projected to reach $55 billion to $60 billion in 2015, up from $16 billion at the end of 2014.
Additional Information and References
- The Fintech trend isn’t that different from digital disruption in media, retail, or any of the other industries: you either have an entire industry or part of an industry that is based on around transferring information and it works much better when that transfer happens digitally.
- Wealthfront – Wealthfront works by first asking a few basic questions – age, income, liquid assets, risk tolerance. It’s the basics of financial planning. Then it provides a financial plan consisting of ETFs – most of them from Vanguard – that track underlying indices in a variety of asset classes, trades based on what the algorithm instructs… personalize, diversify, re-balance.
- To date, Wealthfront has raised $130 million, Motif Investing $126 million, Personal Capital $104 million, Betterment $45 million and FutureAdvisor $22 million.
- The Technology Driven Transformation of Wealth Management… TechCrunch